:: About Us \  :: Our Services \  :: Resource Center \  :: FAQ \  :: Site Map \  :: Contact Us \  :: Home \

Gray grid design Todd L. Herman, Certified Public Accountant
Management Consulting Service

Apple and Oranges — Let's Compare

Quarterly Update — March 1997

I have recently received many questions about the differences between Lotus Notes and Microsoft Exchange. Frequently, the tone of these questions indicates that the person wants assurance that Exchange is comparable to Notes in depth and breadth of functionality. To show that this is not the case, I have prepared the table below showing the Microsoft products that would be required to equal the functionality of the single Notes product.

I should point out that presenting the products in this fashion is not a fair comparison, since the Microsoft products exist in relative isolation, requiring a Visual Basic programmer — having knowledge of all the products — to cobble together a solution that would still not be as robust as Notes. Notes' out-of-the-box functionality is remarkable, and Lotus is moving ahead rapidly with further developments. Already, Lotus has announced two new releases of Notes for 1997. This is on top of three Notes releases in 1996, culminating with Notes 4.5 and the renamed Domino server.

The differences in these key products embody the differences in their companies. IBM and Lotus seem committed to make it easy for businesses to integrate communications, collaboration, and commerce in a single, multi-platform, client/server product. Microsoft develops products that are technically sound individually, but demonstrates a surprising lack of vision and focus by failing to provide an easy way for systems professionals in business — versus technicians or hobbyists — to integrate its hodgepodge of products.

Lotus has clearly proven the strength of Notes' architecture by the ease with which Internet protocols were incorporated into the single Notes product. Notes has all the right ingredients for continued success and, coupled with the financial strength, marketing experience, and database expertise of IBM, presents a challenge that will take Microsoft years to answer.

For these products, the familiar saying "You can't compare apples and oranges" should become "You can't compare an apple and some oranges."

Feature Lotus Microsoft
E-mail
Client Notes Outlook
Server Notes (Domino) Exchange
Internet/Intranet
Client Any browser Any browser
Server Notes (Domino) Internet Info Server
Index Notes Index Server
Page Design Notes Front Page
Browser
Desktop Browser Notes
Internet Explorer
Netscape Navigator
Internet Explorer
Server-Based Browser Notes n/a
Browser Management Notes n/a
Workflow
Development Environment Notes
LotusScript
Visual Basic
Visual Basic Script
Imaging Lotus Notes Document Imaging n/a
Fax Server Lotus Fax Server for Notes n/a
Groupware
Group Scheduling Notes Outlook
Calendaring Notes Outlook
Platforms
Client Windows 95
Windows NT
Windows 3.1
OS/2
Macintosh
UNIX
Windows 95
Windows NT
Windows 3.1 (limited)
Server Windows NT
Windows 95
Netware
OS/2
UNIX
Windows NT

 

As you can see in this update, several of our projects involve Lotus Notes in some way. Not only is Notes an integral part of our internal operations — it has helped us share information and improve our processes, regardless of where we work — but it is also a key part of how we can help companies improve their business processes and systems.

Todd L. Herman

Todd L. Herman

Sign-Up For Our Newsletter

Become a subscriber! Each month, you'll:

  • See real-world examples of how we've helped good companies get better.
  • Get Todd's straight talk on improving your people, your processes, your technology — and, on occasion, yourself.

Sign up now!

Call Us for a No-Obligation Consultation

Think your business could be running better? You're probably right — we'll help you figure out where to begin.

Improving processes and using technology to help people deliver more results. That's what we do.

Call 336.297.4200 or click here to contact us online.

Helping Our Clients

Recent Successes

Assisted a distribution company in designing a more effective and motivating compensation plan for the sales force, helping align this plan with new aggressive company growth and profit objectives.

Designed an expenditure control system for a publicly traded company with twenty-eight sites in twenty-two states, using Lotus Notes as the basis for the application, allowing quick approval and frequent updates on expenditure status between the corporate office and the remote locations.

Started the process of identifying and selecting a suitable vendor for a comprehensive set of financial software for a health care insurer, helping our client make an informed decision.

Assisted a client in a software vendor selection project to identify a budgeting tool, recommend.ing a system to be used as a means to develop budgets with budget reporting capabilities.

Reviewed and analyzed the timeline of a client's month-end closing process, identifying ways to streamline the closing process and take advantage of a new software system.

Upcoming Projects

Conduct a search for a database system to allow our manufacturing client to track and document the commitment, purchase, receipt, estimated pricing, and final pricing of raw materials, allowing validation and confirmation of raw materials pricing.

Develop an accounting policies and procedures manual through a simple Lotus Notes database, documenting steps for a smooth and timely month-end closing process.

Develop a Lotus Notes project log database template, allowing our client to create and maintain independent project logs to collaborate and manage construction projects with key clients.

Track, document, and reconcile all expenditures related to a new building project, providing monthly management reports during the project.

Develop and implement an expenditure control system, using Lotus Notes as the appli.cation tool, allowing quick approval and frequent updates on expenditure status between the corporate office and twenty-eight remote sites.

Assess current systems at two distinct manufac.turing plants to determine if either of these systems — or a different system — is suitable to manage both existing plants plus a new plant, helping management to begin implementing standard systems and processes in all plants.